Page references for folks!
Selva's side of the conflict :
Warrick's side of the conflict :
Namesake has a lot of "everyone is wrong" situations where someone temporarily "wins" the debate until the next page. Selva had time to think while she weaved about why the Shadow would grab her and not Warrick. Warrick did screw up, but Selva build a relationship where he felt he had to be perfect and hide new mistakes. It's a feedback loop both twins need to fix!
Selva first realization of it here : https://www.namesakecomic.com/comic/selva